Why Has NewsGuard Perpetrated Misinformation About GTMO if Partially Funded by the DOD?

March 26, 2023 ~ Commentary by Linda Forsythe

EDITOR’S NOTE: On March 10, 2023, Newsmax released a report verified by C-VINE about NewsGuard being awarded nearly $750,000 from the Department of Defense in 2021.

NewsGuard is a proverbial “fact-checking/rating” agency that has been giving C-VINE News questionable ratings for what they deemed as misinformation, even though open source information has qualified our reports as factual. Source information also included transcripts from GTMO proceedings where appropriate.

We have yet to receive an explanation back on our queries as to why NewsGuard has never fact checked blatantly and provable false articles about American Citizens being detained, held, prosecuted and/or executed in GTMO from various news agencies.

The OMC (Office of Military Commissions) has very specific regulations against American Citizens being held in GTMO.

The following OMC Regulations was sent to me from the Office of Military Commissions (Ron Flesvig), as the Rule of Law on who can be detained, tried, and or prosecuted at GTMO.

The specifics of jurisdiction (who can be tried at Guantanamo) below, from MMC 219 Edition:

From Rule 202 – (a) In general. Any alien unprivileged enemy belligerent is subject to trial by military
commission under chapter 47A of title 10, United States Code.

DEFINITION UNDER Rule 103 (a) (1): “Alien” means an individual who is not a citizen of the United States.

DEFINITION UNDER Rule 103 (a)  (29) “Unprivileged Enemy Belligerent” means an individual (other than a privileged
belligerent) who—
(A) has engaged in hostilities against the United States or its coalition partners;
(B) has purposefully and materially supported hostilities against the United States or its coalition partners; or
(C) was a part of al Qaeda at the time of the alleged offense under chapter 47A of
title 10, United States Code.

Ronald E. Flesvig
Office of Military Commissions – Convening Authority
4800 Mark Center Drive, Suite 11F09-02
Alexandria, VA 22350-2100

(End OMC Quote)
In addition to our NewsGuard questioning, we included a small sampling from many hundreds of reports that allegedly purport American Citizens being held in GTMO, (although a few claim they are Satire in small print).
NONE have been called out or given a negative rating by NewsGuard. The consequences of which have falsely led the public to believe Obama, Hillary Clinton or a whole slew of politicians have been detained, tried or executed in GTMO.

On January 24, 2023, C-VINE reprinted one of many direct responses from us to NewsGuard questioning this, during the last year’s rating process. We specifically requested for NewsGuard to explain why this particular misinformation has gone unchecked from various news agency rating processes, when it is in direct violation of OMC regulations and has mislead the public for years.

If interested, that report is here here that also includes samplings of false reports: https://c-vine.com/blog/commentary-newsguard-rating-process-of-c-vine-part-ii/

The report from Newsmax (below) about NewsGuard receiving funding from the DOD, is a very serious allegation that must be answered. What is going on?

~~~ Linda Forsythe

Left-Wing NewsGuard Awarded Pentagon Contract, Records Show

The Pentagon
The Pentagon (Getty Images)

By Theodore Bunker    |   Friday, 10 March 2023 02:33 PM EST

NewsGuard, a left-wing media monitoring organization which claims to rate the credibility of news websites, was awarded nearly $750,000 from the Department of Defense in 2021 according to publicly available records.

The revelation comes in the latest “Twitter Files” post by Matt Taibbi.

In a series of posts detailing internal communications among Twitter executives, Taibbi suggests a collaboration of government and the company of what appears to be a coordinated effort to censor or slant information available to the public and individuals — particularly conservatives.

Two U.S. agencies he identified included the State Department’s Global Engagement Center and the Department of Defense.

Taibbi was concerned about the government grants to an organization that targets news outlets, writing:

“Some NGOs (non-governmental organizations), like the GEC-funded Global Disinformation Index or the DOD-funded Newsguard, not only seek content moderation but apply subjective ‘risk’ or ‘reliability’ scores to media outlets, which can result in reduction in revenue.”

He continued: “Do we want government in this role?”

Government records show a purchase order from the Department of Defense amounting to $749,387 with the recipient listed as NewsGuard Technologies Inc. Also listed: a start date of Sept. 7, 2021, and an end date of Dec. 8, 2022.

The company’s ratings have been used by advertising agencies such as Publics Group and Magnite, as well as the Pentagon and the American Federation of Teachers.

NewsGuard is a for-profit company founded in 2018 by Steve Brill, a media entrepreneur who has also been a long-time and prolific Democratic Party supporter, including having made donations to former Presidents Barack Obama, Bill Clinton and Sen. Chuck Schumer.

The Media Research Center has examined NewsGuard’s “ratings” system and found the service continually favors left-wing and liberal news outlets as “trusted” and negatively rates conservative ones as not reliable.

Newsguard negatively rates leading conservative outlets like Washington Times, Newsmax, Breitbart, Federalist, Epoch Times, Red State, Prager U, Daily Wire, and others.

Last week, Florida’s CFO, Jimmy Patronis, wrote to Newsguard saying the company’s actions are in line with the “environmental, social, and governance” (ESG) standards used by liberal organizations to blacklist groups that dissent from their views.

Patronis noted that that the Florida Legislature is targeting that in its upcoming session, and that NewsGuard’s efforts appear to be a larger push to create “social credit scores” that will result in “debanking” and “deplatforming” private companies.

Rep. Jim Banks, R-Ind., who chairs the Republican Study Committee, questioned NewsGuard’s neutrality in a letter sent to the AFT last year saying, “the organization regularly gave high marks to obviously progressive and left leaning outlets such as Occupy Democrats, The Nation, and Jacobin, which have published articles promoting progressive views on matters such as riots and property destruction and socialism.”

According to Banks: “These are hardly unbiased entities, and any rating system that ranks them as such deserves our scrutiny. To make matters worse, NewsGuard has even ranked several Chinese state-run media outlets higher — that is, more trustworthy/truthful — than popular conservative U.S. news sources.”

NewsGuard defended the contract, saying it was not “government funded.”

“NewsGuard has been inaccurately described as a “U.S. government funded” entity — which is like saying Verizon is government-funded because some government agencies pay for its phone services,” company spokesman Matt Skibinski said in an email.

“NewsGuard is a for-profit business. We sell licenses to clients to access our data about misinformation and disinformation sources and narratives. While most of our licensees are in the private sector, some government entities license our data about state-sponsored disinformation campaigns targeting Western democracies from places like China, Venezuela, and Russia. We are proud that our data is useful in countering Chinese and Russian disinformation on behalf of Western democracies.”

Editor’s Note: Marisa Herman contributed to this story.

© 2023 Newsmax. All rights reserved.

News Stories Researched and Posted by our Team of Volunteer Citizen Journalists